It's a quiet morning so... v=3=v

[Mounrou]

Estne scriptus haec epistula quod ille stultissimus vir?

Utique frater meus, sicut alibi omnibus.

Каждый должен научиться использовать перевод Google, чтобы вы могли выразить себя так, как будто у вас много языков.

Гугл переводчик это хорошо, но знания лучше.

Lo siento, a usted no le entiendo muy bien, solo puedo leer chino no pero no puedo escribirlo, ¿podría explicar en chino por casualidad? Gracias

Sí bueno, pero solo un poco.


Part A:
製作遊戲沒有意義，但你不需要什麼意義。做你想做的就好。問題是很多人把它當作不止於此的東西，結果分散了注意力，沒有成功，也只有得到很多憤怒。

Part B:
製作遊戲並不復雜，但還是需要基礎的東西。但很多人不只沒有基本規則甚至沒有規則的基本概念，結果不複雜的東西也包括個人情緒和反應的，以一種糟糕的方式不必要地複雜化。

Part C:
爛系統+1

那是因为一旦想要开始做原创规则。。。这个想法一般是基于 我需要这个原创规则。

而不是 我要做一个原创规则给大家玩

Bravo! 

[Ophidia]

Google translate for Latin is actual garbage smh

[Allen Fang]

哇！这是一个外国友人吗？

[Mounrou]

...50%? v=3=v (Just a Chinese-Canadian @hole who don't think there's a point to write stuffs in Chinese most of the time anymore.)

[landbuilding]

事实上，做一个规则应该是有目标受众的，最小单位，一个主持（最早的主持通常是写规则那个），和一个玩家（如果玩家们之后能反过来带团，说明这个规则在这个团内的人们中算是取得了初步成果）
一个规则如果没有玩家，甚至没有多个玩家试用，光靠主持设想其实很困难。另外靠其他网友提建议也没有太大的帮助


同时要有一个相对固定的团，之前就要有一定的时间和精力耗费。对于新人来说往往就陷入了
“我们要有工作经验的人才，不要新手”
“你不给我工作我哪里来的工作经验”
这样的循环


然后就是因为自造规则太多，网友往往不先看完成度和可玩性，而是有没有比较独特的地方，或者至少看起来有玩的欲望

[Mounrou]

Yep.

That's why I always say "making rules" are different from "making it viable for consumption for other people".

Anyone can make TRPGs. It's also very easy to make TRPGs. That's the whole point on top.

Making it properly playable for other people (And we're not even talking about making it interesting enough for others yet...) is VASTLY MORE DIFFICULT.

They are 2(3?) separate issues.
(In a more detail way: Creation > Application > Commercialization. )



The point on top is mostly just an @hole's reaction to people who make rulesets, but somehow treats "the action of making rulesets" by itself, as something special and should be pampered just because they did it.
!!!=_=\

Tl:dr,  If you're so offended when people call you out for making bad products, then just don't release them. Period.
If you're taking it seriously, then let your product be judged on its own, because once you release it it is "just a product".
(And yes, even if it is "free", as long as you are trying to get others' interest, then it becomes a product whether you intend it to be or not.)